Tonneau Cover Guide – Which One You Should Buy – And Why

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

The best tonneau cover to buy is the BAK BAKFlip MX4. But, there is a lot to consider before choosing.

In this article, I will give you all you need to know so you can make a purchasing decision with confidence, knowing you’ll get exactly what you need at a great price.

As you know, there are a lot of things to consider when shopping for a tonneau cover. The first and most important thing to consider is what you need it for. 

Here are some questions to help you figure out what type of cover will serve you best.

Do you haul large cargo frequently?

If you regularly haul cargo taller than your box, you’ll need something that opens fully and allows access to the entire box. This is possible with a soft roll-up style or a folding style, but not a one-piece. 

A soft rolling tonneau cover will easily roll up to the front of the bed and allow 100% access to the truck bed, and it won’t block your view when looking out the back window; the only downfall is that it is easy for thieves to break into.

A hard folding tonneau cover will also allow access to 100% of the bed but will stand up at the front of the truck bed and block your entire view when looking out the back window.

Which Truck Bed Cover is better Roll-up vs Tri-fold.

Will you always need a tonneau cover?

If you only need a tonneau cover for protection from the elements when traveling on a family vacation, then a soft tonneau cover would be your best option because they are less costly than other styles and are easy to remove, and won’t take up much space when stored in your garage.

How much security will you need?

If security is your main concern, then you’re going to want a hard style cover. They are made of rigid materials and are harder for thieves to break into. If you want to know more about how secure a tonneau cover is, I think you’ll like the in-depth article I wrote about the most secure tonneau covers.

How much do you want to spend?

Like anything in life, you get what you pay for. That being said, a soft tonneau cover will be less costly than a hard tonneau cover, and the painted one-piece cover will be the most expensive. If looks and security are big issues for you, you’ll most likely want to go with a one-piece hinged tonneau cover.. 

Is moisture an issue for your cargo?

Hard covers tend to offer the best seal against moisture. Soft covers may or may not supply a decent barrier to moisture, depending on the brand and construction of the cover. It’s all in how it attaches to the truck. For a more in-depth answer please read “Are tri-fold tonneau covers waterproof?

Does appearance matter to you?

We all love our trucks, and how they look is very important to us. Choosing a truck bed cover to compliment that look is half the reason to get one. Fortunately, most brands want their products to look amazing. If it comes down to the style that suits your taste more you might have to compromise looks for function depending on your needs.

Who will install it?

Most covers are easily installed, but maybe you don’t have time or want to be sure it’s done correctly for safety and insurance reasons. It goes without saying if you plan on having a shop do the installation, it will add to the project’s cost—just something to consider.

With all that in mind, we can now look at what types of tonneau covers are on the market.

After a bit of research, I put together this list of my favorite tonneau covers for each type. 

HARD-FOLDING TONNEAU COVERS

Best Overall

Best Value

Honorable Mention

Hard Folding Tonneau Covers

Undercover Flex Hard Folding Truck Bed Tonneau Cover FX31009 Truck Upgrade Advisor which tonneau cover should i buy

Undercover Flex

BAK BAKFlip MX4 Hard Folding Truck Bed Tonneau Cover Truck Upgrade Advisor which tonneau cover should i buy

BAK BAKFlip MX4

Tonno Pro Truck Upgrade Advisor which tonneau cover should i buy

Tonno Pro

Summary

100% BED ACCESS 

STYLISH LOW PROFILE DESIGN

EASY OPERATION

100% BED ACCESS

ULTIMATE SECURITY

STYLISH MATTE FINISH

400 LBS CAPASITY

LIGHT WEIGHT STRONG

SIMPLE SECURITY SYSTe

EZ CLAMPING SYSTEM

Pros

  • Warranty

  • Durability

  • Ease of Use

  • Looks

  • Cost

  • Warranty

  • Easy to Install

  • Water Tight

  • Looks Great

  • Well Made

  • Warranty

  • Easy to remove

  • Weatherproof

  • Sturdiness

  • Value for money

Cons

Rail is might roll into the bed of truck.

Instalation may be callenging.

Some parts are plastic.

SOFT TRI-FOLD TONNEAU COVERS

Best Overall

Best Value

Honorable Mention

Soft Tri-Fold Tonneau Covers

Which tonneau cover should I buy

Tyger Auto T3

buy tonneau cover

SCITOO

buy tonneau cover

Lund Genesis

Summary

US Design Patented

Cover is dual-coated

Pre-assembled horizontal crossbars

Easy no drilling installation

Perfect fit

No-drill installation

Powerful tonneau cover

Built to last

Premium matte canvas
Flawless folding
Lund commitment
5 min install

Pros

  • Looks Great

  • Super Easy

  • Great Price

  • Well Made

  • Perfect Fit

  • Easy to install

  • Value for money

  • Looks great

  • Easy to remove

  • Weatherproof

  • Easy to install

  • Value for money

  • High Quality

Cons

The clamp handles are plastic and could possibly be an issue.

There are no complaints for this product.

Doesnt clamp down very tight near tail gate.

RETRACTABLE HARD TONNEAU COVERS

Best Overall

Best Value

Honorable Mention

Retractable Hard Tonneau Covers

Which tonneau cover should I buy

Gator Recoil

buy tonneau cover

Roll-N-Lock

buy tonneau cover

RetraxONE

Summary

Precise protection
Versatile cargo hauling
No drill installation
Gator guarantee

Unmatched storage
Unmatched style
Unmatched operation
Unmatched ease

Legendary security
Legendary style
Durable construction
Legendary functionality

Pros

  • Easy to fold

  • Easy to install

  • Durability

  • Easy to use

  • Better milage

  • Easy to install

  • Sturdiness

  • Value for money

  • Great Design

  • Easy to install

  • Durability

  • Value for money

  • High Quality

Cons

Plastic retaining clips that hold stabilizer bars might break.

Might be a little short at the tailgate.

Difficult to fit in with an existing drop in bed liner.

HARD ROLL-UP TONNEAU COVERS

Best Overall

Best Value

Honorable Mention

Hard Roll-Up Tonneau Covers

Which tonneau cover should I buy

TruXedo Sentry



which tonneau cover should I buy

BAK Revolver X2

Which tonneau cover should I buy

BAK Revolver X4

Summary

Industrial strength vinyl
Effortless one hand rolling
No drill installation
3-year, no hassle guarantee

Patented rotational locking rails

Durable aluminum slats

3rd brake light visibility

3-year guarantee


Durable aluminum slats

Locking rails to secure the cover


Full bed access

5-year guarantee

Pros

  • Easy to use

  • Water resistance

  • Easy to remove

  • Easy to install

  • Value for money

  • Reliable security.

  • Slam latches

  • Easy to remove

  • rear view visibility

  • Looks great

  • Easy to install

  • Value for money

  • Easy to open

  • Quality design

Cons

The tailgate does not close while the cover is latched.

Can't roll it up if it's below freezing.

Does not allow multi pro tail gate to work correctly.

Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Covers

Best Overall

Best Value

Honorable Mention

Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Covers

Which tonneau cover should I buy

Tyger Auto T1 

buy tonneau cover

TruXedo Lo Pro

buy tonneau cover

TruXedo TruXport

Summary

Full bed access


Latch lock system at the tailgate


Easy No-Drilling installation

Superior weather resistance

Full access to stake pocket holes

Lifetime, no hassle warranty

High quality leather-embossed vinyl

Keeps cargo dry and secure

No drilling or special tools necessary

Pros

  • Looks great

  • Easy to install

  • Easy to remove

  • Weatherproof

  • Value for money

  • Easy to install

  • Easy to use

  • Value for money

  • High quality

  • Weatherproof

  • Easy to install

  • Value for money

  • High Quality

  • Sturdy 

Cons

Will stretch in the first few weeks.

Only one latch on the left side.

Having to unclip both sides of the cover to open.

Conclusion

You now know all the styles of bed covers on the market and you now know which of those styles suit your needs. The next step is to find the brand that you feel most confident in.

I hope this article has been helpful to you and you’re closer to making a decision. If you want to learn more I think you’ll like this article too What Is The Best Tonneau Cover For Your Money? Things To Consider.

Check out this comparison Roll n Lock vs Retrax Tonneau Cover.

For you, Silverado fans, read Best Silverado Truck Bed Cover.

Still, need more info? Read this: BAK BAKFlip truck bed cover review.